Why Not Use Javascript Handlers On The Body Element?

Question

As an answer to the question of 'How do you automatically set the focus to a textbox when a web page loads?', Espo suggests using

Solution 1:

Using onLoad is becoming less and less common because callbacks can't be stacked using this method, i.e. new onload definitions override the old ones.

In modern frameworks like jQuery and its .load(), callbacks can be stacked and there are no conflicts when using different scripts, plugins, etc. on the same page.

Also, it is widely regarded good practice to keep the markup separate from the code, so even if one would want to use onload (which is perfectly okay if you control the complete environment and know what you're doing) one would attach that event on the scripting side either in the head or a separate javaScript file:

window.onload = function() { document.getElementById...... }

Solution 2:

There's nothing wrong with using the onload attribute in the <body> element, provided:

you have complete control of the page
no other script that you use on the page currently or could have in the future will try and set an onload handler on the body element or the window object
you know your own mind and are happy to have a small piece of script in your mark-up.

It's also worth noting that <body onload="..."> is a part of a formal standard (HTML 4) while window.onload is not, although it is implemented in all the major browsers going back many years.

Solution 3:

Disregarding the issues of whether inline event handler attributes are a wrongness for a moment, the onload event is a poor place to put an autofocuser, since it only fires when the whole page is loaded, including images.

This means the user will have to wait longer for the autofocus to occur, and if the page takes quite a while to load they may already have focused elsewhere on the browser page (or chrome, such as the address bar), only to find their focus stolen halfway through typing. This is highly irritating.

Autofocus is a potentially-hostile feature that should be used sparingly and politely. Part of that is reducing the delay before focusing, and the easiest way to do that is a script block directly after the element itself.

<inputid="x"><scripttype="text/javascript">document.getElementById('x').focus();
</script>

Solution 4:

I suppose this has to do with other javascript files also. If some of your javascript files contain a handler for body onload, and if you supply an inline body onload handler in your page then the handler inside the script won't be executed.

Solution 5:

Well, '<id>' is an invalid id value if you ask me. I wouldn't use any characters like this.

And for good practice, it's better to use window.onload IMO and place it in the <head> tag. OR Better yet, you can move it to a .js file and cache it for speed.

JavaScript Guy